LOL that would actually probably be a good idea, we would avoid annoying everyone with our nonstop Kpop spamming on this thread haha
AND I KNOW!! Sherlock is honestly such an amazing song, it's the song that really cemented them as Kpop legends imo, it's still absolutely iconic even to this day
And yup, it's crazy hard to sing, but they pull it off nearly flawlessly in all their live performances, they're the best male group in terms of vocal consistency imo.
I absolutely LOVE the Sherlock remix too, I actually like it better than the original lol. I like Taemin's verses in the remix a lot better, and
Jonghyun's scat is just so goood. Even though it's the Japanese version,
this is still my favorite performance of Sherlock by far, I just love how Taemin sung his lines
here. And their outfits and stage presence here were the best imo
I still don't get how they can sound so good singing live while they're doing that insane choreo, they're just too good
But, yeah, for as much as I like EXO, you're right lol
Even though I genuinely do like EXO's sub vocalists (I actually quite like Suho's voice), with the exception of Chen (and Baek & D.O to an extent, but they're not as good as Chen is live), EXO isn't nearly as vocally consistent as SHINee is. And that's mainly because, like you said, they have too many members for their own good.
They're like forced to split up lines between every member, even the ones who can't sing as well, which overall gives off the impression that they're not as vocally skilled as SHINee, even though their 3 main vocalists are really really good (according to
this chart, they're actually better than SHINee's on average. But I still prefer SHINee lol).
They just get to sing less per average on a song compared to Jonghyun, Onew, and Taemin because they have that much more members, which is kinda annoying lol.
I wouldn't mind if EXO was condensed to 5 members tbh, all we really need is Chen, Baekhyun, D.O, Chanyeol, and maybe Suho/Xiumin/Lay.
I think that's why I like EXO-CBX so much, the line distribution is a lot more fair since it's split across way less people, so the vocal performance comes off as more impressive imo, since Baek and Chen sing 66% of each song lol
Now listening to:
Super Junior- Black Suit
This was such a good comeback honestly, probably one of my favorite comebacks of the year. I love Siwon's part in the prechorus
here. I just still really miss Kyuhyun's and Ryeowook's voices :(
So glad I got to at least Kyuhyun's voice in
this song, he honestly has one of the best voices in all of Kpop, he has one of the nicest and most natural vibratos I've ever heard lol
Offtopic but this song REALLY reminds me of a SHINee song. I could totally see Jonghyun or Taemin or something singing this part