Copied from replying to the micro tempest in the Kajura quality discussion thread which got locked while I was typing it.
"Woah, woah. Was my Akiko Shikata mention a provokation, after all? I certainly didn't see this debate coming.
Let me clarify. I'm pretty much an Akiko fan now. But at the time I heard Katayoku no Tori, I thought it was an awesome song, and then I heard Inori no Kanata, and it was also an awesome song, but using a similar recipe.Now let's make ut clear that by recipe I don't mean melody, structure or arrangement separately - rather the blend of those. You must have noticed that if I like the artist, I don't have many problems with hearing similar stuff from him, but at the time, Inori no Kanata was probably the reason why I didn't have a further urge to google Akiko. I thought, Oh great, she composes beautiful songs like these, but I can do with these exact two in my playlist.... It was only when I heard an extract from Ricordando il Passato that made me search for full version and stumble upon Harmonia album. Now, I can't support Raf's opinion on it, since Harmonia (coupled with VII I found at the same time) was what made me an Akiko fan. Different approach to chorus, intence pop rock, grand hymns and sweet ballads combined, switching from high pitch wailing a-la Yousei Teikoku to solemn operatic vocal...
And who even needs Utsusemi as n example, when Umineko no Naku Koro ni is almost like two songs in one?
I think the whole argument has stemmed from the attitude that repetitiveness means complete loss of originality. Re-read my post, please. I said "get repetitive AT TIMES". Not copypasting songs, but simply using some models of distributing chords, instruments, solos, vocals and so on. I think any composer comes to have such a set of models of his own, and repeating them, while inarguably less cool than costant invention of new models would be, isn't abnormal. Thus, I've heard Utsusemi single and I can't say I've found anything above what I expected from Akiko based on previous experience. But I can't say that disappoints me in the least.
"