Vocal Discussion of Yuki's Singers

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cerise
  • Start date Start date
She sounds perfect/ on tune, it's true. But she obviously looked like strained herself to reach those high notes. In magnolia, she pushed herself to do higher harmony in Keiko and Hikaru's part. What we're concerned here is not because she doesn't sing good or she sounded off tune throughout the song, but the way she pushed herself to sing in higher notes, and her higher notes is not as smooth as it's used to be.

Well, I'm not being harsh to HimeWakana and Ophelia, but this way of you two fangirlism towards Wakana is not really good. All you hear is that she sounds perfect, which is maybe on every performance you two thought that way. But because of that you failed to see her struggle to reach those notes that seems much more than her previous performances and her vocal smoothness that already became lessen in this After Eden live. For me, Wakana's vocal movement from normal to falsetto was really bad in this live.
 
Re: Vocal Ranges of Yuki's Singers

I noticed when she sang Eden in After Eden Special live concert, she really pushed herself, making Keiko and Hikaru's voice almost unheard.
 
No problem Ritardando *__* You can say whatever you think .. I honestly did not notice all this effort for reaching high notes (she seemed to me particularly tired in Ongaku) .
Anyway I really hope she'll recover her shape as soon as possible!!
 
Anyway, I noticed Wakana's voice in Lirica is extremely high. The song itself is perfect. I tried singing it and it left me breathless before the song even end.
 
Re:

HimeWakana said:
Anyway, I noticed Wakana's voice in Lirica is extremely high. The song itself is perfect.
Click to expand...
+1! I would like to see a live version of this song!
Click to expand...

Me too. I tried searching for the live but there is none. Also I would like to see "Ashita no Keshiki" live. Anyway HimeWakana, what does the symbol "+1" mean in your post?
 
Me too. I tried searching for the live but there is none. Also I would like to see "Ashita no Keshiki" live. Anyway HimeWakana, what does the symbol "+1" mean in your post?
Click to expand...

Yep "Ashita no Keshiki" is another song , that I would like to listen :sohappy: and "+1" means that I agree with you :XD:
 
Re:

ritardando said:
She sounds perfect/ on tune, it's true. But she obviously looked like strained herself to reach those high notes. In magnolia, she pushed herself to do higher harmony in Keiko and Hikaru's part. What we're concerned here is not because she doesn't sing good or she sounded off tune throughout the song, but the way she pushed herself to sing in higher notes, and her higher notes is not as smooth as it's used to be.
Click to expand...

OMG yeah...my BD came (finally) and I watched red moon...sometimes she looked like she had cramps or something :omg: It was a great performace, loved her singing...but her face was at times scary :cry:

Even if Wacchan can still sing on tune and manage her high notes well, I'd still rather she didn't look so tortured whilst singing...I mean, half the pleasure of seeing them perform live is watching their happy faces :cry:

Fingers crossed that she'll have rested and be back to her normal self on their next live and put this bad patch behind...:touched:
 
Even if Wacchan can still sing on tune and manage her high notes well, I'd still rather she didn't look so tortured whilst singing...I mean, half the pleasure of seeing them perform live is watching their happy faces
Click to expand...

This. That's why I really concerned of her health now. She looked like she extremely struggling and like tortured when singing some songs...
 
Just saying... if Wakana's struggling, it's likely her high notes weren't perfect.
 
^
Looking at this, maybe I have to edited my post. Well, on some songs her notes were not on tune. I totally forgot about the kajiuran part of Kugatsu that sounds extremely terrible. Although I still say that most of her notes was still on. Magnolia too, have some off notes, like "shiroku" in "samayoi mezasu basho ni shiroku".. well, in adore (currently listening this one) her high notes in Kajiura were not on tune, and a bit-lower for me.

I rewatched Eden and realize how much mistakes Hikaru made here. Her all higher notes were totally off...
 
I don't think her being on tune should even be mentioned, since the live's been edited. There's no way of knowing how off-tune she really was, unless someone bootlegged the live...

Of course, I could start explaining my belief of Kala in general not being constantly off-tune, but that would probably send Grunty into hysterics :psst:
 
^
I'm on your side with the belief of Kala in general not being constantly off tune...And just like what I've said on AE DVD thread, it's kinda hypocrite to criticize some singers when we can't sing as good as them. Add to the part that their concert's ticket most likely sold out. For me, no matter how you love the singer, but if they totally fail live then you won't watch their concert. But seeing this fact Kala couldn't be totally fail in live. Maybe giving the score of 7 or 8 out of 10, because tbh there are lots of artist that promoted as group-singer who can't sing as good as them.

And this will send Grunty into hysterics too. :psst:
 
Re:

ritardando said:
it's kinda hypocrite to criticize some singers when we can't sing as good as them.
And this will send Grunty into hysterics too. :psst:
Click to expand...
Just a sidenote: Grunty can sing :sparkleguy:
 
Re:

ninetales said:
I don't think her being on tune should even be mentioned, since the live's been edited. There's no way of knowing how off-tune she really was, unless someone bootlegged the live...

Of course, I could start explaining my belief of Kala in general not being constantly off-tune, but that would probably send Grunty into hysterics :psst:
Click to expand...

:)

Alphard Sokaina said:
Just a sidenote: Grunty can sing :sparkleguy:
Click to expand...

No, I can't. I like singing but I definitely do not think I can. Let's stick to that version, k? :D

PS. I'd also appreciate you not reposting my years old stuff, lol. Thank you.

:cry:
 
Re: Re:

grunty said:
Alphard Sokaina said:
Just a sidenote: Grunty can sing :sparkleguy:
Click to expand...

No, I can't. I like singing but I definitely do not think I can. Let's stick to that version, k? :D

PS. I'd also appreciate you not reposting my years old stuff, lol. Thank you.
Click to expand...
As you wish :chuu:

PS. I wan't going to do it.
 
Re: Re:

Alphard Sokaina said:
ritardando said:
it's kinda hypocrite to criticize some singers when we can't sing as good as them.
And this will send Grunty into hysterics too. :psst:
Click to expand...
Just a sidenote: Grunty can sing :sparkleguy:
Click to expand...


Ah, totally wanna hear it! :XD:
 
ah lol talk about grunty,
I still have lacrigrunty and gruntoria :psst:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top