Lorde-Kowz
I have reached Yuki nirvana
It might be like Adore; the preview sounded like a generic anime opening, but it turned out to be a great song IMO.
Or something which is called "Fan boy-ism" : Worshipping everything as if gold, platinum, diamond, or god-like which one has made even if the work is objectively shit.
icedphoenix said:As a matter of curiosity, how do y'all tell when Kaori or Yukido is singing? I more or less have Wakana and Keiko down (well, Keiko's voice is kinda difficult to NOT notice) but without video, I've never figured how Kaori or Yukido's distinguishing features.
ahehehe. .wild imagination u got there.wouldn't that be too hard on keiko since she's a contralto? anyway.the possibility doesn't closewintersviolet said:i would love to hear wakana singing lower harmony though, i've always heard her sing higher. if that's true maybe keiko could try higher harmony
*winter's wild imagination runs away*
wintersviolet said:i would love to hear wakana singing lower harmony though, i've always heard her sing higher. if that's true maybe keiko could try higher harmony
*winter's wild imagination runs away*
Nick Hunter said:Objectively? Come on, being a fan[boy] and being objective are antonyms. It's a matter of whether the artist's style and way of writing clicks something inside you or not. The ratio of the tracks that do and the intensity only define the degree.Or something which is called "Fan boy-ism" : Worshipping everything as if gold, platinum, diamond, or god-like which one has made even if the work is objectively shit.
The problem is, if a person is not a fan, that doesn't guarantee objectivity. You may play the song to an uninvolved person who has never heard of the artist in question, and still his/her opinion will be based on whether the song appeals to them personally or not. Being a critic is a tough job, and I heard it requires music education and special training. How many of us here have one, really?
So with my judgement of Yuki's works acknowledged as utterly subjective, I don't even begin to be a critic. Why bother searching any faults at all, then? Instead, I want to know if the new song has that elusive and not quite describable something that once made me a Yuki Kajiura fan. While the quality and impression may vary, everything I've heard so far happens to have it. Does that make me a fanboy?
I'd say it's rather that you don't like what you hear because you don't hear that something that once made you a Yuki Kajiura fan. All the variety of opinions is ultimately based on this. To each his own, everyone may like Yuki's music for specifically defined traits and merits, judging new works by the presence of these. But nobody is truly objective.
wintersviolet said:i would love to hear wakana singing lower harmony though, i've always heard her sing higher. if that's true maybe keiko could try higher harmony
*winter's wild imagination runs away*
ninetales said:wintersviolet said:i would love to hear wakana singing lower harmony though, i've always heard her sing higher. if that's true maybe keiko could try higher harmony
*winter's wild imagination runs away*
Hmm, that might not work for Wakana. Remember when she sang 'toki o tomete' in Magia? I think her voice is too light and operatic-sounding to go that low, so she sounded a little choked to me. As I recall, no one on CPM particularly liked her singing that. I think Wakana is limited to singing higher harmony, unfortunately
But as for Keiko singing higher harmony...I adored it when she sang 'mukidashi no hontou ga' higher in the lives of Sprinter, so more of that would definitely be welcome, at least for me