I went through my favorites and came up with the following. Sorry for length
Love Come Down is one of mine. I disliked it from the very first listen, and I kept on disliking it until I heard the live version and realized: the
song isn't bad, just the
guitar! I love the live, but not the studio, because of Nishikawa.
Mata kaze, too. At first the bass really hurt my ears, and I thought it was rather overwhelming hard rock. Eventually my horizons broadened, and apparently I had some minor hearing loss (or maybe the change in headphones helped?), because now I think it's awesome and the bass doesn't bother me anymore
With
Ongaku, I had a similar experience to Love Come Down. I didn't particularly love the studio version, but when I heard the live, I realized that despite the fact it's a little bit of a plain song, it's actually really fun.
Ashita no Keshiki never grew on me...but I suppose I shouldn't mention it here, because I still don't like it
I wasn't impressed with
Kimi ga hikari at the beginning, but now I can hear more of the emotions underlying the song.
I thought
Haru wa was very, very depressing when I first heard it. As usual, it took listening to the live
(and that heart-breaking solo violin) to change my mind.
Kugatsu...well, I'm still not that wild about it, but I found that I really enjoy playing it on the piano
I had a complete change of heart on
Mune no Yukue, believe it or not. I didn't hate it at first, but I wasn't impressed. Now, though, I'm grooving to the chorus and everything
At first
Tasogare no Umi was kinda loud and shrieky for me. Thankfully, there's no Nishikawa solo in it, so it grew on me gradually. Now I love it so much I'm planning to sing it at AB '12
I remember starting to listen to
Inca Rose and being completely bored. Somewhere along the line, something changed, and I fell in love with it. It's one of my favorite Kajiurago songs now.
Mostly because of Koichi-san's beautiful solo...
Same for
(We Are So) Together. I listened to it, was completely discouraged by Saeko Chiba's voice, and then listened to it again and thought it was lovely, sad, wistful...
Senya Ichiya kinda freaked me out at first, but once I got past the weird arrangement, I started to like it, and I love the chorus especially now.
I wasn't that wild about
Sis Puella Magica at first, although I did like it. But now...now it sticks in my head at random points of time
What was disconcerting about
The Moving Era for me at first was Yuri Kasahara; basically, I didn't like her voice at all because of her heavy vibrato. Now I've gotten used to it in most songs, and The Moving Era especially sticks out for me because of how epic it is.
I have to admit that
Jubilee has grown on me. I'm used to Eri's sound in it, and I just enjoy how fun it is.
Didn't like
I Swear at first. Still don't love it, but I'm more acclimatized to it and it's a catchy melody.
The first time I listened to
Everytime You Kissed Me, I remember giving up completely about 30 seconds in, but I forced myself to listen to it in its entirety when Fiction II came out. I really love it now, and I love playing it on the piano. Especially Morio's bass
I probably shouldn't mention
Hitorigoto either, because I still don't like it
My Green Park at first was just very bland and boring. Now I listen and think to myself, "Hey, Nishikawa certainly can arrange pretty well."
Hoshi ga Tokete I found extremely depressing. Unfortunately I still do, but now I like listening to it despite that...