X
xcad
Guest
LOL
definitely not google translated either. ;D
definitely not google translated either. ;D
That said, I do feel that Wakana is pretty unstable recently. She sounded amazing in the 2010 Blu-Ray. In the last year or so, she seems to have good and bad days, and sometimes my throat hurts in sympathy when I hear her sing (again, this is all from YouTube, I've only been to AFA Malaysia and the concert yesterday). Again, considering she has to sing 2 hours more or less non-stop (they talk during MCs, so the only real rest is the encore interval), I think it's seriously tough and probably detrimental in the long run. It doesn't help that she has so many events, being in both FJ and Kalafina as well as doing promotions, radio, live appearances etc.
Yuki88 said:ps. if you meant Tokyo Dome City Hall, it's not Tokyo Dome itself despite being in the same complex.
ninetales said:Sorry to pop in here, but for those mentioning the DVDs/Blu-rays as examples, they're all heavily edited with Studio Magix, as are all official video releases from both Kalafina and FJ. Hence, it's very tough to hear high-quality unedited lives...
...and this might be me overreacting but I even hear a difference in Wacchan's voice in their studio-recorded singles (e.g. in yane no mukou ni, she sounds a lot sharper on the 'yane no mukou niiiiiiiiii' than I thought she would).
To me, at least, her voice sounds thinner and weaker, and seems to have lost some of its old smoothness and elasticity (I also noticed she seems to struggle with changing notes with legato - she often breaks off and makes it choppy where it sounds like she tried to join them together).
It sounds like over-exertion of her voice, so I guess, understandably, given Kala's growth in popularity, she's just tired from countless rehearsals and performances (for FJ too and remember, Yuki uses her a lot as one of the main vocals in FJ songs), MCs, radio shows, interviews etc. (not to mention she's the one who loves talking the most XD).
Regardless, I'm sure she'll find a way to cope and get used to whatever's tiring/stressing her out. They say the voice is like a muscle right? So perhaps (I'm hoping) after a while she'll adjust and her voice will get stronger and return to its old self. In spite of it all, though, her voice hasn't lost any of its charming appeal to me.
I haven't been to a live myself so I really don't have any right to say whether they're good or bad, but I don't think the girls are unaware of whatever problems they have with lives (in fact, Wakana openly acknowledged that they're her biggest problem) so I trust that they're working hard, rehearsing and practising to fix any issues.
I trust that with more time and accumulating experience, they will get better and better.
Mwhlr said:Wakana is indeed still young. I believe that your voice might not fully mature until you are over 35 years old, so her voice could still be developing.
Her parts in Yuki's compositions could really strain a singer who doesn't have proper technique or just lacks the natural range
However, the girls have all had vocal coaching, according to the interviews, and probably still do - I'm sure she wouldn't be singing in that range if it was dangerous for her.
Whatever the case, hopefully it will be resolved!!!
Although, one thing about those old rock stars to bare in mind - half of them couldn't sing in the first place! xD