If you still can't understand what I'm saying, it's your problem, not mine. How are you not understanding that just because something is generic, it does not necessarily make it bad? I don't know why you're going out of your way to tell me that it'd still have a kick-ass instrumental. I never said it wouldn't. Is generic now being conflated with negativity because if that's the point of this discussion then there is a problem with everything that has been said until now. SNSD's Genie is generic but once the vocals are removed the instrumental is still amazing on its own.It would still have what I personally consider a kick-ass instrumental. If you know another composer/band that have a song with oblivious instrumental flavour, I'd definitely appreciate the recommendation.
For science purposes, here's oblivious noHanae, noKeiko, with a shitty reverb on Wakana, quickmixed by yours truly: ("cpm")
Spoiler: I still like it. A lot. How Wakana goes off on that "wasureta" still amuses me greatly, too.
Whatever do you mean.
I'm not familiar with heavy metal, other than Japanese bands like Yousei Teikoku if you consider them heavy metal (I wouldn't know, for me it's all pop), so I won't comment on that but (was this what you had in mind in the previous quote?): So removing Kajiurago from a Kajiura track which has it makes it lose (a lot of) the Kajiura-flavour? No shit. Like I said in my previous post, I'm not sure what you were getting it.
Why did you change your post? :^)We're obviously done. Enjoy your stay.
There's a clear cutoff point where things turned to shit, however. That point was Heavenly Blue. Some people would argue that TTB or Misterioso were it, but they at least seemed to keep the right kind of feeling that I'd expect to hear from Kalafina even if they weren't necessarily up to the same level of quality.
Because I'm tired and I expected you to post a kick-ass instrumental track that would have at least some of that oblivious flavour that would make me think "Yep, oblivious without Hanae and Keiko has no Kajiura identity whatsoever (heck, it's own even), it's just like a lot of other composers' songs". That is what I would consider generic, what you are arguing from what I'm understanding and what I don't agree with (at least in oblivious' case because I myself haven't heard a track like it).Why did you change your post? :^)
I like it, it has that same feeling as storytelling did with me where I could listen to it on the train, watching the world pass me by
A Kala-meleonIn terms of Kalafina's style I feel it's like a chameleon.
It was easy since half of the song is the same thing over and over again