Nice Lists!! ^^
Here is my somewhat controversial one lol
Sometimes i feel like the only one who really loves After Eden. Sure Magia and Snow Falling suck, but a good majority of my alltime fav Kala songs are on that album (Eden, in your eyes, Neverending, Symphonia, Mune no Yukue) so I have to give it S tier. With the exception of Magia and Snow Falling, the rest of the songs on that album would be about A tier for me too.
A lot of random bsides have songs I'd also individually consider S tier (Koibito, Utsukushisa, Kantan katan, etc.) but the rest of the songs on the single hold them back. And for some singles its the opposite, like believe is a shit tier song for me but i love in every nothing + lapis so :P
Consolation I've always found a tiny bit overrated, its a very cohesive album but with the exception of Signal, door, and Yume no Daichi it doesn't really have any stand out tracks to me.
FoTW I also find a bit overhated lol, all the singles suck and some of the bsides are meh (Hokage is probably my least favorite Kalafina song ever) but how godly Usumuraski and monochrome are brings the album up overall for me. I also really like musunde (it's grown on me a lot over the years), sorairo and identify. The album is nowhere near as cohesive as Consolation, but it has much higher highs (and also lower lows) . How bad the lows are though drags it down a lot for me.
I've always found Lacrimosa insanely overrated lmao. never cared much for Gloria either.
Storia is also kinda overrated imo, but lirica brings it up to B. HnS itself would be about B tier for me, but I dont really like sapphire so it gets C.
Kagayaku I've also always found a tiny bit overrated, the only reason i sit through it 99% of the time is for keikos bridge lol
One Light and KnGnNw are C bc I only really like Tsuioku + Samidare, everything else is meh.