^ I will list Sorrow as a very honorable second place
I think I'll just get Noir II out of the way...
Eighth Game ~ Noir OST II
Le Grand Retour - 5
Secret Game - 5
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 5
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 5
Power-Hungry - 5
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
I am going to give voting a bit of a break, though
Killing
A Farewell Song
Indio
Le Grand Retour - 5
Secret Game - 5
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 5
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 5
Power-Hungry - 5
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 5
Colosseum
- Despair
Le Grand Retour - 5
Secret Game - 5
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 6
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 4
Power-Hungry - 5
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 5
I'm getting nervous already. I leave the topic for A DAY at work, and A WHOLE ROUND passes?
Coming in high spirits to vote for Lullaby, and I can only see the tombstones...
Checking the previous pages got me a mention of some songs being easier predictable winners than others. So, where's Canta Per Me?
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 5
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 6
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 4
Power-Hungry - 5
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Colosseum
- Despair
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 5
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 7
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 3
Power-Hungry - 5
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 6
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 7
Salva Nos II - 5
Maze - 5
In Peace - 5
Despair - 3
Power-Hungry - 4
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
@Nick: It was just me and Winter last night, so I'd say that's why CPM or Salva Nos didn't end up winning. Rounds with lots of voters might end up with the more well-known songs winning...
Sorry about the quick round, though. I'm not quite sure how that happened.
+ SN II
- Maze
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 6
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 7
Salva Nos II - 6
Maze - 4
In Peace - 5
Despair - 3
Power-Hungry - 4
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Oh well. But I'll be keeping a closer eye on this topic from now on.
+ Colosseum
- Despair
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 6
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 8
Salva Nos II - 6
Maze - 4
In Peace - 5
Despair - 2
Power-Hungry - 4
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Don't be sorry, part of the reason songs win is you have to be here and thus seventh heaven died
+Secret Game
-Power-Hungry
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 7
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 8
Salva Nos II - 6
Maze - 4
In Peace - 5
Despair - 2
Power-Hungry - 3
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Le Grand Retour - 6
Secret Game - 7
Fake Garden - 5
Les Soldats II - 5
In Memory of You - 5
Colosseum - 8
Salva Nos II - 7
Maze - 3
In Peace - 5
Despair - 2
Power-Hungry - 3
Black is Black - 5
Canta Per Me II - 5
At Dusk - 5
Premonition - 5
Killing - 5
A Farewell Song - 5
Indio - 4
Ah, that reminds me, I have to go look up all the second-places!
EDIT
Done! Natsu no Ringo, Nowhere, Tasogare no Umi, Progressive, Hoshikuzu.