Kajiura-sensei Favorites ~ Elimination Game

  • Thread starter Thread starter ninetales
  • Start date Start date
grrrr aki.

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 4
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 8
magnolia - 8
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 11
 
huehuehue

+ neverending
- magnolia

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 4
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 9
magnolia - 7
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 11
 
+ neverending
- magnolia :plot: eh eh

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 4
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 10
magnolia - 6 :knife:
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 11
 
+ Kugatsu
- Magnolia

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 5
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 10
magnolia - 5
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 11

Seriously someone just put Mune no Yukue out of its misery? (I can't cos it was Keiko's longest sounding song, lol.)
 
grrr you all.

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 5
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 9
magnolia - 6
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 11
 
I don't have the heart to kill Mune no Yukue :TdT:

+ symphonia
- Kugatsu

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 4
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 9
magnolia - 6
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
Mune no Yukue - 1
symphonia - 12
 
But I do, since most of it was my doing :knife:.

+magnolia
-Mune no Yukue (bye)

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 4
destination unknown - 11
neverending - 9
magnolia - 7
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
symphonia - 12
 
+DU
-Kugatsu

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 9
magnolia - 7
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
symphonia - 12
 
+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 8
magnolia - 8
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 7
symphonia - 12
 
+ Kagayaku
- magnolia

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 8
magnolia - 7
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
Grrr aki.

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 7
magnolia - 8
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
*smirk*

+ neverending
- magnolia

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 8
magnolia - 7
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 9
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 7
magnolia - 8
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
Hmm, getting harder to choose now.

+sandpiper
-neverending

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 6
magnolia - 8
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
yes seasonreaper!

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 3
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 5
magnolia - 9
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12

I'm fine with everything as long as it's not neverending. even sandpiper.
 
so for you sandpiper>>neverending?

+ neverending
- Kugatsu

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 2
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 6
magnolia - 9
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
le dando's After Eden song ranking : symphonia = magnolia = Magia > destination unknown > Kagayaku Sora > Kugatsu > Eden > Kotonoha (pretty but boring) > in your eyes = Mune no Yukue > sandpiper > neverending = snow falling. I remember liking Kotonoha and Mune no Yukue for awhile but maybe that's just me consoling myself because Mune no Yukue has the most prominent Keiko vocal in this album and Kotonoha has the least amount of Hikaru in this album (since track 01 - 07 is all Hikaru track). Now that I'm more objective I think this is my final rank. At least sandpiper has a very touching lyrics. I just don't get what Kajiura's trying to explain/show with neverending - plus it's way more less inspired than sandpiper. snow falling is simply a disgrace of snow is falling.

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 2
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 5
magnolia - 10
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
tbh I can't remember ever reading the translation of neverending. I just like how it sounds.
precisely because Keiko has more lead in Mune no Yukue I thought you would like it more. But I understand not listening to it as much anymore, because I don't either (and when I do, it's Consolation live ver, because ermaigosh Keiko).

the more I think about it, symphonia might be my favourite of AE (album-only songs). The lyrics, and especially Kajiura's notes about the song, make me want to cry but while smiling. There's a reason my sig has lyrics from that song.

I feel like I should like magnolia more, but unless I'm in the mood, the song never sticks with me.

+ Kagayaku
- Kugatsu

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 1
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 5
magnolia - 10
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 9
symphonia - 12
 
I think I get to like Mune no Yukue because of Consolation Special Final as well. Just like you said, ermaigosh Keiko is really lovely in that live). I remember magnolia is the first track that brought smile to my face when I first listened to After Eden album. The song's arrogance and how cold it sounds makes it an instalove even though I don't really understand all the lyrics. I really like the lyrics after I read the translation of that song, plus the girls (especially Keiko and Hikaru) carry the song's emotion/meaning really well with their singing. I am a Keiko fanboy but there are some songs where Keiko's voice doesn't really work for me.

+ magnolia
- neverending

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 1
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 4
magnolia - 11
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 9
symphonia - 12
 
I feel like magnolia today so I got to magnolia.
Also Kagayaku is the only Kalafina PV that has made me doze off infront of the com.

+ magnolia
- Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa

sandpiper - 10
Magia - 6
Kugatsu - 1
destination unknown - 12
neverending - 4
magnolia - 12
Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa - 8
symphonia - 12
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top