Marina Inoue - Houseki Live @ Anipara Ongakukan

  • Thread starter Thread starter maxwell9
  • Start date Start date
M

maxwell9

Guest
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hO1GIiwRR-A[/youtube]

i'm truly disappointed, i thought her live perormance was going to be better than keiko's, but in spite of i still don't like her version, keiko's live performance is way better =(.
 
The chorus is where Marina so owns the song. I think it's a pretty good performance seeing as she's no longer singing the song as Cosette, but as Marina.
 
she sang with higher octave than the single version, i think.
 
Re:

SAME said:
The chorus is where Marina so owns the song. I think it's a pretty god performance seeing as she's no longer singing the song as Cosette, but as Marina.
Click to expand...

I agree, she sings the chorus very good, but in everything else she sings too low.
 
Re:

maha_gnosis said:
she sang with higher octave than the single version, i think.
Click to expand...

No no, it's the same key. Maybe it sounds higher because she sounds lower on the studio version.

I also prefer Keiko's live version! :dote:
 
the keys are right, but she seems uninspired, i can't feel the song.... i guess she's more of a studio artist. plus, KEIKO already said in interviews that she can barely contain her excitement on stage!! she puts out a lot of feeling. :nosebleed:
 
This is one of my fav songs , and i have to agree with you , i prefer keiko :/ marina isent so good on this one live««.
sigh im dispointed tooo :( :cry: :uh..:
 
Keiko is a very good live performer... Her Houseki's is more powerful and a bit aggressive, but Marina's is a bit more feminine and emotional...

However, I think Marina did not well in this live.. The beginning part is absolutely failed for live performance and she almost can't maintain the power of her voice in the 2nd and 3rd hooks. The feeling that (at least, I think) she tried to fill when she sang is different from Keiko's and I prefer this one, even she can't present that feeling as well as Keiko did in her live.
 
Poor girl, I can't put too much criticism on her. She's, way before a singer, a voice actress after all, and she happened to sing the ending of the anime where she voiced the main character. Looks like it was mostly studio work, but the song is beautiful anyway, and we have our beloved Keiko to sing it live for us~<3
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top