CPM's Official Kalafina Song Ranking

S

Seasonreaper

Guest
OK, so I don't really know if this should be here or elsewhere, but since we had the 'rank all the songs' thread in this subforum I guess it works.

Basically this is a structure I've seen on other forums before regarding different things, but people rank a top 10 of their favourites with weighted values and using those values it creates an overall ranking based on multiple peoples favourites.

So basically you rank a top 10 like this:

#1 - 10pts
#2 - 5pts
#3 - 5pts
#4 - 3pts
#5 - 3pts
#6 - 3pts
#7 - 1pt
#8 - 1pt
#9 - 1pt
#10 - 1pt

And then the results are added to a core list that I'll keep track of in this initial post (if anyone plays along :touched:) and we can see which songs are most loved overall by the most people. I have a feeling this may make some people want to hit me or something, having to rank a single song so highly above others :ohoho:.

If we get a few results in here I'll throw in my own choices, too.

Current Ranking:
#1: red moon - 71pts
#2: sprinter - 65pts
#3: Oblivious - 62pts
#4: Seventh Heaven - 58pts
#5: アレルヤ (Alleluia) - 48pts
#6: Magia - 38pts
#7: lirica - 35pts
#8: Signal - 31pts
#9: 君の銀の庭 (Kimi no Gin no Niwa) - 29pts
#10: 追憶 (Tsuioku) - 28pts
#11: Lacrimosa - 25pts
#12: serenato - 24pts
#13: 夏の林檎 (Natsu no Ringo) + Sandpiper - 23pts
#14: 花束 (Hanataba) - 22pts
#15: Destination Unknown - 20pts
#16: また風が強くなった (Mata Kaze ga Tsuyoku Natta) - 19pts
#17: 闇の唄 (Yami no Uta) - 17pts
#18: 光の旋律 (Hikari no Senritsu) + Moonfesta - 16pts
#19: Progressive + Gloria + 音楽 (Ongaku) - 15pts
#20: obbligato + to the beginning - 14pts
#21: ARIA - 13pts
#22: Symphonia + 明日の景色 (Ashita no Keshiki) - 11pts
#23: In Every Nothing + storia - 10pts
#24: 君が光に変えて行く (Kimi ga Hikari ni Kaete Iku) + Heavenly Blue - 9pts
#25: Lapis + Door - 8pts
#26: 満天 (Manten) + Adore - 6pts
#27: Eden + Misterioso + fairytale + うつくしさ (Utsukushisa) + I have a dream - 5pts
#28: 屋根の向こうに (Yane no Mukou ni) + snow falling + テトテトメトメ (Te to te to me to me) + 星の謡 (Hoshi no Utai) - 4pts
#29: 夢の大地 (Yume no Daichi) + 木苺の茂みに (Kiichigo no Shigemi ni) + 傷跡 (Kizuato) + Kyrie + 胸の行方 (Mune no Yukue) + ひかりふる (Hikari Furu) - 3pts
#30: consolation + love come down + Magnolia + Believe - 2pts
#31: interlude 01 + Ring Your Bell (In the Silence) + 春は黄金の夢の中 (Haru wa Kogane no Yume no Naka) + 輝く空の静寂には (Kagayaku Sora no Shijima ni wa) + Neverending + fantasia + Sapphire - 1pt


Voters: shiro, PopSock, george1234, ritardando, nodame89, Kohaku_, Kirito, Adhara, chrisgarci, casarina26, Smoshes, crystalpink, HimeWakana, Lord Starfish, myself, aki, Nightmare, Cerise, Yukito, lapis, Varete, takfogger, sprinterXkyrie, Moonlight04, Spirica Rose, littlefelicita, T-rond, Sofia

Songs not yet voted for :rain::

Seventh Heaven: Overture
Red Moon: Intermezzo
After Eden: Kugatsu, In Your Eyes, Kotonoha
Consolation: Al Fine, Mirai
Other: Interlude 02, Finale, Dolce, Prelude, Ring Your Bell, Koibito no Mukashigatari no Yuugure no
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hmm… this was difficult. :desksweat:
The last two I've been really into lately for some reason so I decided to include those.

1. lirica - 10
2. Red Moon - 5
3. Lacrimosa - 5
4. fairytale - 3
5. sprinter - 3
6. oblivious - 3
7. ARIA - 1
8. serenato - 1
9. Manten - 1
10. obbligato - 1
 
1. oblivious - 10
2. Kimi no Gin no Niwa - 5
3. seventh heaven - 5
4. Yami No Uta - 3
5. snow falling - 3
6. sprinter - 3
7. Hikari No Senritsu - 1
8. interlude 01 - 1 (yes really!)
9. Natsu no Ringo - 1
10. Consolation - 1

Lists are impossible :blood:
 
Why "official" ? :XD:

1, sprinter
2. lirica
3. kimi ga hikari ni kaete iku
4. matta kaze ga tsuyoku natta
5. natsu no ringo
6. signal
7. hanataba
8. seventh heaven
9. ashita no keshiki
10. gloria

I agree, list is impossible!

for other more ten I would add

11. kimi no gin no niwa
12. serenato
13. door
14. lacrimosa
15. magia
16. alleluia
17. love come down
18. fairytale
19. storia
20. I have a dream
 
Last edited:
1. Alleluia
2. Hanataba
3. seventh heaven
4. lapis
5. oblivious
6. sprinter
7. Kimi ga Hikari ni Kaete iku
8. signal
9. adore
10. obbligato

I don't even know. If i could cheat I'd put more than one song on each tier lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: aki
1. Magia
2. Lacrimosa
3. Eden
4. Manten
5. Serenato
6. Moonfesta
7. Yami no uta
8. Seventh Heaven
9. Mata kaze ga tsuyoku natta
10. Te to te to me to me

So when everyone write his favourites @Seasonreaper calculate points?
 
That's the plan, yes. If there's any new posts when I check back I'll update the list in the original post. And it's 'official' because the info comes from the collective community base of everyone who's here and comments*.


*not actually official
 
I feel like this belongs to the general&spam though... it's like the Elimination Game, but this time for the whole discography
 
It was painful :touched:

1 - oblivious
2 - signal
3 - seventh heaven
4 - Alleluia
5 - destination unknown
6 - sprinter
7 - I have a dream
8 - ARIA
9 - Door
10 - fairytale
 
#1. signal - 10pts
#2. obbligato - 5pts
#3. oblivious - 5pts
#4. ARIA - 3pts
#5. seventh heaven - 3pts
#6. Hikari no Senritsu - 3pts
#7. Tsuioku - 1pt
#8. red moon - 1pt
#9. consolation - 1pt
#10. love come down - 1pt

Mostly the same as my other list with some tweaks. HnS has been stuck in my head for the past few days.
 
please do not kill me if I rank heavenly blue high, lol.
1 - kimi no gin no niwa
2 - heavenly blue
3 - storia
4 - moonfesta
5 - hikari no senritsu
6 - obbligato
7 - to the beginning
8 - Lacrimosa
9 - kagayaku sora no shijima ni wa
10 - fairytale

EDIT: Apologies for the duplicate. Changes marked in bold.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It was hard to choose :orz:

#1 - Symphonia
#2 - Misterioso
#3 - Ashita no Keshiki
#4 - Heavenly Blue
#5 - Mata Kaze ga Tsuyoku Natta
#6 - Destination Unknown
#7 - Love Come Down
#8 - Magia
#9 - To the Beginning
#10 - Ring Your Bell (In the Silence)
 
please do not kill me if I rank heavenly blue high, lol.
1 - kimi no gin no niwa
2 - heavenly blue
3 - storia
4 - moonfesta
5 - hikari no senritsu
6 - obbligato
7 - to the beginning
8 - Lacrimosa
9 - hikari no senritsu
10 - fairytale

I wont :knife:.

You put Hikari no Senritsu twice, though.
 
Lemme see...

#1 - 10pts- To the Beginning
#2 - 5pts- Hikari no Senritsu (sobbz, can't I rank it joint top? :cry:)
#3 - 5pts- Aria
#4 - 3pts- Yane no Mukou ni
#5 - 3pts- Alleluia
#6 - 3pts- Kimi no Gin no Niwa
#7 - 1pt- Ashita no Keshiki
#8 - 1pt- Tsuioku
#9 - 1pt- Believe (for sure I'm getting butchered... :hide:)
#10 - 1pt- Red Moon

Honorary:
Heavenly Blue, Neverending, Kugatsu. But never mind.
 
#1 - 10pts- Red Moon
#2 - 5pts- Alleluia
#3 - 5pts- Sprinter
#4 - 3pts- Sandpiper
#5 - 3pts- lirica
#6 - 3pts- Signal
#7 - 1pt- Symphonia
#8 - 1pt- Tsuioku
#9 - 1pt- Serenato
#10 - 1pt- Magia
 
Omg, selecting top 10 songs was so hard.....

1. Red Moon
2. Sprinter
3. Tsuioku
4. Oblivious
5. sandpiper
6. Obbligato
7. destination unknown
8. Signal
9. Door
10. Gloria

I keep changing my list....Hard to make up my mind :cry:
 
1) Alleluia
2) Lacrimosa
3) Red moon
4) Yume no daichi
5) Gloria
6) Serenato
7) Seventh heaven
8) Kyrie
9) Kimi ga hikari ni kaete yuku
10) Door

It's so difficult to do a selection!!
 
1. seventh heaven
2. Magia
3. Kimi no Gin no Niwa
4. Alleluia
5. Hoshi no Utai
6. Symphonia
7. red moon
8. Manten
9. Door
10. Hikari no Senritsu

This list was thrown together slightly arbitrarily. #1 is the only one I'm absolutely certain of.
 
Got a lot of responses, so things are starting to take form. Can't say I'm surprised Oblivious is at the top, but Alleluia is much higher than expected. No love for Utsukushisa is making me sad, though. Also no Ongaku and only one point for Kyrie surprises me. A few more songs would end up with around two thirds of Kalafina's discography in the system which is pretty impressive. If anyone sees anything I've messed up, please do mention it.

Going to add in my own points now.

#1. Sandpiper - 10pts
#2. Utsukushisa - 5pts
#3. Hanataba - 5pts
#4. red moon - 3pts
#5. serenato - 3pts
#6. lirica - 3pts
#7. Kimi ga Hikari ni Kaete Yuku - 1pt
#8. Hikari no Senritsu - 1pt
#9. Tsuioku - 1pt
#10. Magnolia - 1pt
 
Back
Top